Thesis Database

We have developed the following database of research theses on bullying from all academic institutions in the UK and Ireland. The aim of this database is to assist those who are interested in the field of bullying and want to see what research has already been done. We have attempted to ensure that we have included all relevant theses here; but if there is an omission please let us know by emailing geraldine.kiernan@dcu.ie.

The database is here for information purposes. Those who want access to the texts of the theses need to contact the author, the relevant institution, or both.

Filters
Reset
How well does a cognitive model predict post traumatic stress symptoms in incarcerated young offenders, and what is the relationship between posttraumatic stress symptoms and bullying behaviour in this population?
2007
Short, V.
University of Oxford

Objectives:  The study aimed to determine the prevalence of posttraumatic stress symptoms in a population of incarcerated young offenders, and to test the applicability of a cognitive model of PTSD to this unique population.  It explored whether there was a link between reported bullying behaviour and posttraumatic stress symptoms, and investigated hyperarousal as a possible mediating factor. Design:  A cross-sectional, questionnaire based study design was used. Method:  56 incarcerated young offenders participated in the study.  Four questionnaire measures were administered in a single interview, and additional information was collected from the young person’s prison life. Results:  A high prevalence of posttraumatic stress symptoms was found in the study population.  Significant correlations were found between posttraumatic stress symptoms and negative appraisals, and cognitive factors predicted variance in posttraumatic stress symptoms over and above non-cognitive factors.  No relationship was found between bullying behaviour and overall posttraumatic stress symptoms although significant correlations were found between hyperarousal and indirect bullying behaviour and total frequency of bullying behaviour. Conclusions:  The study provided support for the important role of cognitive factors in posttraumatic stress symptoms and suggests that a cognitive model can be usefully applied to a population of incarcerated young offenders.  For the most part, the results suggested that no relationship exists between bullying behaviour and posttraumatic stress symptoms, but a specific relationship between hyperarousal and some forms of bullying behaviour was found.  Further research is needed to fully understand the experience of bullying in this population, and to examine the causes and consequences further.

Learning about and living with a diagnosis of asperger’s syndrome or high-functioning autism: a qualitative study in adolescents
2007
Johnson, Beth
University of Southampton

Asperger’s Syndrome (AS) is a lifelong developmental disorder that affects numerous aspects of people’s lives, particularly social skills associated with understanding and interacting with others. AS is similar to High-Functioning Autism (HFA); clinicians and researchers often consider these concurrently, as here, although there is a greater focus on AS in this paper. Individuals with AS/HFA appear to be at a greater risk of ‘psychiatric co-morbidity as they transition from childhood to adulthood. The revie~ :paper considers possible barriers to a successful transition through adolescence such ;as social skills, stigma, bullying and adjustment. The empirical paper presents a qualitative study designed to understand some of these barriers faced by adolescents (aged 12-18) with ASIHFA Results indicate that the participants progress through a process of discovering the meaning of AS/HFA and that this is affected by other issues such as managing the label and experiencing stigma, bullying and difficulties with friendships.

Preventing and countering bullying behaviour amongst students in Irish schools at a nationwide level
2007
Minton, Stephen James
Trinity College Dublin
Vulnerability and abuse: an exploration of views of care staff working with people who have learning disabilities
2007
Parley, Fiona Forbes
Robert Gordon University

In recent years there has been increased focus on vulnerability and abuse however greater attention has been paid to this in relation to children, elders and in domestic situations. Within learning disability service there has been increasing attention on physical and sexual abuse as well as attention being given to abuse as it is perceived by people with learning disabilities. The aim of this study was to explore the views of staff working within learning disability services regarding their views of vulnerability and abuse. A phenomenological approach was adopted, as this is a subject about which little is known and the lived experiences of care staff and the meanings that they attach to them were being explored. Semi-structured interview was the chosen method for data collection. Twenty informants shared their views in this study. The data generated were themed and the findings were presented in two different but complementary styles: case studies and themes representative across the entire sample. This research has highlighted a number of important issues. There is considerable difference in the meanings given to vulnerability by care staff and the range of meanings are further complicated when notions of risk are considered. A model is presented that illustrates experiences of vulnerability and confidence of the individual the impact of various experiences on those states. For example negative experience of bullying might increase vulnerability whilst positive family support might engender feelings of confidence. The study showed that staff are more influenced by personal and family values than by policy. Though this study focused on adult protection policy it was evident that this also applied in the case of other policy. The strong influence of personal values pervades all aspects of care. This was evident in the views of informants regarding abuse. Abuse is considered to range in severity from bullying, which is seen as prevalent but to an extent unpreventable, to sexual abuse which is considered by most to be taboo. Neglect and infringement of rights were in the main not seen as abuse with both being attributed to ignorance. Power, authority and/or control are felt to be essential in the management behaviour that challenges and is justified to that end. In the context of adult protection a model for safety planning is proposed that shifts the emphasis away from risk avoidance toward an enabling person centred approach that recognises the importance to the individual of excitement in life that also may involve risk.

The subject of social work: diminished subjectivity’ in contemporary theory and practice
2006
McLaughlin, Kenneth Gerard
Manchester Metropolitan University

Throughout its history, the activity, or profession of social work has been influenced by dominant political and social mores. This thesis charts such developments in the United Kingdom, locating them in not only the socio-economic circumstances of each period, but also in relation to changes within social theory, specifically those from a left wing political tradition. Charting the move to the contemporary period, it is argued that the current epoch is one of ‘diminished subjectivity’, where people are viewed as more objects than subjects, and are more likely to be viewed as either vulnerable or atavistic, rather than as having the potential to create a better society. The thesis starts with a history of social work from its charitable origins in the seventeenth century through to the early 1970s. It then analyses intellectual developments in the understanding of human subjectivity, in particular that of Hegel, Marx, the Frankfurt School, and the influence of postmodernism/poststructuralism to our understanding of the human subject. It is argued that a common intellectual current is one of ‘diminished subjectivity’. We return to the history of social work in chapter four, analysing the changes from the 1970s onwards, with particular emphasis on the overt politicisation of the profession. Combining this with the theoretical analysis of chapter two, the influence on social work of wider intellectual and political change becomes evident. The contention is that social work itself, for all its talk of ’empowerment’, is influenced by the tendency to view the subject with suspicion, and to demean it at the very moment it endeavours to ’empower’ it. The thesis then examines manifestations of ‘diminished subjectivity’ in the arena of social work. Four specific but interrelated areas of concern to social work are highlighted, with particular focus being on the arena of adult mental health. The first is the rise of the discourses of pathology and abuse. Whilst these increasingly common concepts have affected both social work policy and practice, social work itself is partly responsible for the popularity of such constructs. The second is the current pre-occupation with risk minimisation, or risk management, and this is analysed in relation to mental health policy and practice at the level of statutory powers and civil containment. From this focus on the more overt coercion within the mental health field, we turn thirdly to the constructions of stress and bullying. The fourth focus is on ‘identity politics’, in particular the rise of the psychiatric ‘survivor’. The penultimate chapter discusses the public/private divide as a theme which cuts across all the previous chapters, and addresses some of the implications of the erosion of this boundary. The concluding chapter summarises the thesis and discusses recent critiques of social work from within the profession. It is argued that the developments discussed within the thesis should not be seen in isolation; but rather that all share a common perception of the human subject as fragile, dangerous, or both.

Individual differences in physical and relational bullying roles: implications for intervention initiatives
2006
Woods, Sarah
University of Hertfordshire

Bullying behaviour is a widespread problem among primary school children that can have serious negative consequences.  However, few studies have carried out detailed investigations regarding the characteristics associated with different bullying roles.  The character profiles and individual differences associated with different bullying roles were investigated in this thesis through a series of studies that considered behaviour problems, physical and psychosomatic health, academic achievement, and emotion processing abilities.  Direct and relational bullying was considered for bully perpetrators, victims and bully/victims.  The latter category was defined as children that are involved in both bullying others, and at other times are victimised.  Overall, results revealed several distinct behavioural characteristics for direct and relational bullying roles, not previously reported.  For example, direct bully/victims had the most problematic behaviour profiles, whilst in contrast, relational bullies were intelligent, healthy individuals, with few behaviour problems.  The impact of various school factors such as class size, and school location were also investigated in association with the prevalence of bullying roles.  Findings uncovered that small school and class sizes, located in rural locations were associated with a higher incidence of bullying behaviour.  Results concerning the individual differences for bullying roles provided several implications for investigating whether they are related to school anti-bullying policies, and the development of a novel intervention programme.  A discussion of the findings is provided in light of more recent studies. Different theoretical orientations are addressed together with a review of methodological issues associated with the studies in the thesis, and future directions.

Quest for identity: young people’s tales of resistance and desistance from offending
2006
Murray, Cathy A.
University of Stirling

This thesis explores how young resisters and desisters in their teenage years maintain their resistance to and desistance from offending and asks to what extent they are agentic in the process. The term ‘resister’ refers to those who, according to a self-report survey, have never offended, and the term ‘desister’ to those who have offended and then ceased for at least twelve months. By situating desisters analytically adjacent to resisters, I have moved towards conceptualising desisters as current non-offenders. Desisters may have shared a past with persisters, as they have both offended. However, desisters share their current experience, that of maintaining non-offending, with resisters. It is this obvious, yet largely ignored, link between young resisters and desisters which underpins the thesis. Two qualitative methods, both of which elicited young people’s own perspectives, were employed between 2003 and 2005. Secondary analysis of 112 qualitative interviews with resisters and desisters in their teenage years was conducted and peer led focus groups (in which a young peer, rather than an adult researcher, acted as the facilitator) were held with 52 teenage resisters. Young people’s resistance to offending does not feature prominently in the literature. When it does, it is often associated with a state of innocence or passivity, while young desisters are said to ‘grow out of’ offending. This emphasis on an absence of offending, rather than on actively attained resistance, reflects an adult oriented view. The thesis challenges this by drawing on the sociology of childhood, a theoretical perspective which has not previously been applied to young people’s resistance to and desistance from offending and which emphasises young people as agentic. Their agency is evidenced by the findings. Chapters Four and Five report how young people employ numerous strategies of resistance and desistance and Chapter Six how that they face trials and tribulations in maintaining their nonoffending, while Chapter Seven focuses on the ‘being’ rather than the ‘doing’ of sustaining non-offending. It is the work of Derrida that enables the argument to be taken a step further. Derrida’s (1981) assertion is that binary oppositions are rarely neutral, but that one is the dominant pole. For example, in Western society the first of the following binary oppositions are usually regarded as the dominant or privileged pole: white/black, masculine/feminine, adult/child. In respect of the binary opposition at the heart of the current thesis, namely offender/non-offender, the non-offender is – from an adult perspective at least – the dominant pole and the non-offender is hailed as the norm. By contrast, several findings in the thesis point to the fact that the dominant pole in the binary opposition for young people is the offender rather than the non-offender. First, the discourse of young resisters and desisters suggests a view of the offender rather than non-offender as the norm. Secondly, many resisters and desisters face trials and tribulations, such as bullying, relating to their nonoffending status. Yet, if it were the case that the non-offender was the dominant pole and was privileged by young people (as it is in the adult population), resisters would not be penalised in such ways for not offending. Thirdly, some of the strategies used by resisters, such as involvement in anti-social behaviour, signify an attempt to compensate for their non-offending status. Again, if the non-offender was the dominant pole in the binary opposition, far from resorting to mechanisms to compensate for their non-offending behaviour, this behaviour would be encouraged, as it is by adults. This inverted world has implications for young resisters and desisters. Their resistance is to be understood in the context of an expectation of offending, rather than non-offending. Contrary to the notion of the pull of normality bringing desisters back to a non-offending state, the pull of normality among young desisters – and many resisters – is better understood as being towards offending. Resistance, evidenced by the strategies and trials and tribulations of resisters and desisters, is against this pull. Moreover, as non-offending is the modus operandi in the adult world, to be an adult non-offender requires less effort. For a young person, being a non-offender is more challenging than it is for adults and maintenance of resistance constitutes a struggle not previously reflected in adult representations. Adults, not having taken account of the different modus operandi of the young person’s world, have not attributed agency to resistance and have underestimated young people’s struggle to maintain resistance. The strategies demanded of resisters and desistcrs to maintain non-offending and the trials and tribulations which they face when they do have heretofore been overlooked.

Women engineers in Britain, 1945-2000
2006
Wray, L.
Open University

This thesis looks at the work of women engineers in the period of 1945-2000.  Its central focus is the impact gender had on the likelihood of a woman making such a career choice, on the training to become an engineer and on women’s lived experiences in the work place.  It discusses the impact of the equality legislation and considers the effect that the characterisation of engineering as a male profession had on the numbers of women in engineering and on their treatment. The thesis approaches these subjects through a study of the experiences of a group of women engineers.  Their life histories are set against the social and economic changes that occurred over the period.  It encompasses both women who were engineers at the beginning of the period and those from later generations.  The use of oral history allows a rounded picture of the changing experiences of women engineers, their career expectations and the degree of success that they achieved. The thesis argues that the history of women engineers has been largely ignored. While their experiences have paralleled that of women in other careers, the continued overwhelming dominance of the profession by men has resulted in a number of assumptions regarding discrimination and harassment that remain unproven.  It demonstrates that the social stereotyping of engineering discourages many women from considering the career, thus perpetuating both gender inequality and the myth that women are unwelcome in the career.

Exploring homophobia and homophobic bullying in irish second-level schools
2006
James O'Higgins Norman
University of London, Institute of Education

This thesis explores the related concepts of heteronormativity and homophobia and their connection to homophobic bullying in Irish second-level schools. The research undertaken for this thesis involved one hundred interviews with pupils, parents, teachers and senior management teams in six second-level schools in the Greater Dublin area. The data from these interviews revealed an understanding of sexuality among participants that was binary in nature in that they (particularly pupils) understood there to be two opposing sexualities, heterosexual and homosexual, and they believed that heterosexuality was the only legitimate or normal sexuality. Close contact with members of the same sex or with gay or lesbian was considered dangerous in that one might be contaminated or turned homosexual and consequently it was considered justifiable to isolate and even ridicule those considered to be gay and lesbian in schools. Homophobic name-calling was also used by pupils to deride those who were not necessarily considered to be gay or lesbian. The data also revealed that for the most part teachers accepted homophobic name-calling and other behaviours as a normal part of the school environment. Teachers were unaware of their role in perpetuating the status quo regarding homophobic bullying. However, teachers did report that they had to be seen to uphold the religious ethos of their schools in relation to homosexuality and as such a culture of silence reigns where sexuality and homosexuality are concerned. The role of the Catholic Church as patron of the majority of Irish schools and its teachings against homosexual behaviour is identified in this thesis as a significant mitigating factor against teachers taking action against homophobia and homophobic bullying. For their part, parents admitted that they would be sad if their sons/daughters were gay, mostly because they would be fearful for how they would be received in school and society. Although they did want schools to include some education about sexual orientation in their programmes. This study highlights the need for clearer policies regarding gay and lesbian issues in Irish schools as well as pre-service and in-service training in equality issues for teachers.

Attachment histories of reception class children and roles in bullying situations
2006
Potter, Amanda
University of Central Lancashire

Bullying research has provided a wealth of information and a depth of understanding that has led to the development of intervention strategies in schools. However, despite this extensive research, bullying continues to be a significant problem. It has been suggested that working with children or with schools may not be enough to solve the problem and that it may be necessary to include parents as part of the solution, especially if the antecedents originate and are consistently reinforced at home. Research that has considered factors relating to family functioning and the relationship between the caregivers and their children provide support for this argument, but research in this area is scarce. The main aim of the present research was to investigate family backgrounds, parenting styles and the personal characteristics of parents and children involved in bullying situations in order to identify effective routes for intervention. More specifically, it focused children’s attachment styles and the roles they adopted in bullying situations at school. A longitudinal design with mixed methods was adopted involving 28 pre-school children and theft caregivers. The children were ‘new starters’ at one of three schools and at the start of the investigation they were aged 4 years – 4 years and 11 months and their primary caregiver’s ages ranged between 29 and 53 years. Primary caregivers participated in interviews and exercises about themselves and theft families and observations of the children occurred in different settings at school during their first year. It was predicted that a link between the childrens’ attachment type and the roles they adopted in bullying situations would be found. However, no evidence was found to suggest a link between childrens’ attachment style and bullying. Despite this, interesting trends were found. These are considered and the difficulties and limitations of the investigation are discussed.

Anti-bullying interventions in North Yorkshire secondary schools: an evaluation of evidence based approaches
2006
Richards, A.E.
University of Leeds
Bullying in the workplace
2006
Shaw, Tracy
Dublin Institute of Technology
Surviving through adversity: the experiences of overseas black and minority ethnic nurses in the NHS in the south of England
2006
Alexis, O.
University of Surrey

Aim: The aims of this study were to explore, describe and develop a greater understanding of the experiences of overseas black and minority ethnic nurses in the NHS in the south of England. Methods: This study utilised a combination of qualitative and quantitative approaches underpinned by interpretive phenomenology.  The qualitative phase consisted of 12 semi-structured face-to-face interviews and the findings informed the focus group interviews, of which four were conducted.  The quantitative phase, a survey, informed by the findings of the qualitative phase was conducted with 188 overseas nurses across 15 NHS Trust hospitals in the south of England. Findings: The qualitative findings revealed five main themes such as: Being thrown into an unfamiliar world, encountering marginalisation and experiencing inequalities in the world, surviving in an everyday world, living in an everyday world and making a new world and these themes encapsulated their experiences.  Overseas nurses indicated that they had encountered discrimination, lack of equal opportunity, bullying, separateness and a host of other encounters that appeared to have affected their experiences of the NHS.  The survey showed that overseas nurses employed in NHS hospitals in London were more likely to perceive themselves to have been promoted, supported and have aggressive behaviour directed at them in comparison to those in NHS hospitals in non-London regions.  The survey also revealed that African nurses were more likely to perceive themselves as being treated less favourably than their overseas counterparts. Conclusion: Both phases showed that overseas nurses encountered difficulties and variations in treatment in the NHS in the south of England and combining the two approaches helped to confirm and reinforce the findings.  This study’s results add considerably to the body of knowledge on the experiences of overseas nurses and have significant implications for nursing practice, management and health policy.

An investigation into self-harm in primary school pupils aged 8-11 years old
2006
Burnett, A.
Lancaster University

Self-harm has been on the rise in the UK in recent years.  A review of the literature was conducted which suggested that this increase was also evident in adolescents, and possibly children.  The literature described several factors associated with self-harm, including depression, anxiety, anger, self-esteem and bullying.  Research using children in UK community samples was lacking, as well as research exploring the factors that are associated with self-harm in this age group. Therefore, the present study was carried out using a cross-sectional survey design, to measure levels of self-harm in children aged 8-11 years, and to assess which factors were associated with self-harm.  Logistic regression analyses were then used to explore independent factors influencing self-harm. These were significant differences between those children who self-harmed and those who did not in their levels of anxiety, depression, self-esteem and bullying.  There were no gender or age relationships with self-harm. The regression model successfully predicted self-harm, although was more successful at predicting the absence of self-harm.  With a significance criterion of p<0.05 only two of the five factors entered emerged as independent predictors.  These results indicated that the lower the child’s anxiety levels, and the higher their self-esteem, the less likely they were to self-harm. Further research was suggested examining the utility of the self-harm questionnaire developed, and the impact of teacher training on levels of self-harm.  Replication of the logistic regression analyses with a broader sample was recommended, as was whole school approaches designed to boost self-esteem and resilience in young people.

The presentation of bullying in contemporary teen fiction
2006
Hodson, K.A.
University of Exeter

Bullying is currently a very emotive and well-publicised issue, featuring frequently in TV programmes and newspapers.  It is no longer accepted as an inevitable part of school life affecting only weak and inadequate victims, but, instead, as a social ill, with long-term psychological effects on both bully and victim, that needs to be eradiated from schools and work places. This research project provides a detailed exploration of fictional representations of bullying in contemporary teen fiction.  It approaches the main research question, “How is Bullying Presented in Contemporary Teen Fiction”? through four subsidiary research questions and interviews with some of the writers in the desk study, against a background of children’s/adolescent literature criticism and psychological, sociological and educational research on bullying in schools.  Thus, the research project utilises current academic thought in two different fields: English and Education. Through the first subsidiary question, the patterns in the presentation of bullying are explored.  Issues of gender, modes of aggression and types of bullying (racial, sexual and organisational) are discussed.  The focus of the research narrows into examining the construction of the bully and victim experience through the second and third subsidiary research questions respectively.  Contemporary presentations are compared with the presentations in generic boys’ and girls’ school stories and considered in the light of current thinking in bullying research.  The fourth subsidiary research question refocuses the research on the narrative design of novels in the desk study by exploring the common strategies writers use in narratives dealing with bullying and the nature of the resolutions to ending the bullying relation offered to readers.  These are considered further as Entwicklungsroman through adolescent literature criticism and notions of adolescent growth, power, maturation and alienation.

Negotiating identities: the experiences and perspectives of Pakistani and Bangladeshi disabled young people living in the u.k
2006
Ali, Zoebia
Coventry University

Employing the sociological concept of reflexivity throughout the research process has led me to argue that there is no one universally successful adult research role, or research tool best suited to gaining young people’s opinions. Any research techniques need to be applied critically. Further reflection on issues which arose from interaction with gatekeepers and respondents throughout fieldwork led to the recognition that emotional involvement and management are also an important aspect of research relationships. In turn this required me to question how my own values and beliefs have influenced the research process and how the research process has influenced the data collected. My research also has two key areas of originality in terms of substantive and theoretical development. On a substantive level, my findings illustrate the complex realities of identity negotiation in the lives of young Bangladeshi and Pakistani disabled people in relation to ethnicity, religion, ‘race’ and gender. This has implications for theory development within the sociology of childhood and disability studies, particularly in the areas of body, identify and self. My findings illustrate how respondents struggle to define selfhood in meaningful and fulfilling ways and show evidence of agency and ingenuity. Respondents’ identities are neither totally imposed nor are they totally chosen or discarded at will. That is, respondents were not simply involved in cultural reproduction characterised by mimicry, but capable of social action. This calls for the development of a social model of disability which is open to the diversity of all disabled young peoples’ experiences. My findings also add to existing debates in policy and practice within the context of these young peoples’ lives. Findings illustrate a need for service providers particularly within educational, health and social service sectors to re-evaluate and adapt existing policies and practice within the areas of combating bullying, communicating health problems, and improving leisure facilities and also suggest that young people would benefit from more guidance and support at school when choosing future career paths and/or academic goals. This thesis and the research on which it is based represent a challenge to previous work by focusing on Pakistani and Bangladeshi disabled young people’s own accounts of their lives.

The social organisation of bullying in nursing: accounts of clinical nurses and nurse managers
2006
Lewis, Malcolm Allan
Manchester Metropolitan University

This research explores the social organisation of bullying in UK nursing from subjective accounts of clinical nurses who were self-referred “targets” of bullying, and nurse managers (a potential “bullying group”).  Focusing on a nationwide sample of 10 clinical nurses, and 10 nurse managers from an Acute Hospital Trust, bullying is identified as a social phenomenon primarily mediated through workplace interactions.  Previous research indicating bullying as being mainly psychological/personality mediated is questioned by applying a Symbolic Interactionist approach to its study which has not previously been attempted. Using both vignettes and relatively unstructured interviews bullying is perceived as intentional and well planned, it’s temporal and processual nature established, and its impact on professional working examined. A mechanism of bullying awareness has been identified in both bullies and targets by a re-examination of Awareness context Theory (Glaser and Strauss 1965). This provided a new focus on the bullying process, enabling a more comprehensive understanding of bullying events within a specific occupational group; nurses, which had not before been attempted. Nurse accounts of bullying identify bullying negotiations in the NHS as being open to manipulation by the bully; and groups and individuals with specific agendas who may impose their definitions of the situation on to them. Such actions leave bullying targets at a distinct disadvantage in gaining redress for their perceived bullying. I conclude that awareness of such issues and examination of negotiations in context can aid in developing more effective bullying interventions and policy. These often remain inadequate, frequently being based on previous quantitative study research, which has failed to appreciate bullying as a complex interactive event in the workplace.

Has a restorative justice approach a role in tackling bullying in primary schools?
2006
Argue, Ellen
National University of Ireland, Galway
Analysis of legal protection of victims of discrimination and harassment and development of strategies for reform
2006
Middlemiss, Sam
Robert Gordon University

The theme, which I have rigorously pursued and developed during my research career, is legal protection for victims of harassment and discrimination.  These terms are used here in their broadest sense and encompass various kinds of undesirable behaviour.  The victims of these types of behaviour have been traditionally disadvantaged because their legal rights have been disregarded and consequently they have been given little or no legal protection (e.g. victims of sexual harassment or stalking). They are often the weaker party in a relationship or someone who is not afforded due care or consideration by another party whose actings adversely affect them.  As a consequence they will suffer economic loss and/or physical or mental harm to their person. Often the legal process they must follow to secure redress is weighted against them.  This could take the form of evidential difficulties (e.g. proving an employer’s vicarious liability in discrimination cases) or having to utilise judicial procedures that are inaccessible.  In some instances there are inherent inequalities between the treatment they receive (e.g. homosexuals, women) within the legal system as compared with members of other groups (e.g. men and heterosexuals). The research is intended to highlight the difficulties faced by these groups and identify possible legal solutions.  It could involve recommendation of a course of action that can be pursued on their behalf by legal practitioners (e.g. applying existing laws that are untried in a particular legal context).  Alternatively the courts handling of a case may be the subject of constructive criticism (e.g. interim relief for victims of stalking). In the context of analysis of legal protection for victims of discrimination and harassment, the Government has often been encouraged to introduce legal rules for the first time to provide protection to disadvantaged groups (e.g. protection of the employment rights of homosexuals and lesbians).  The Government or the legislature have also been encouraged to amend existing legislation to ensure better protection is available or to comply with legislation emanating from the European Union (law on sexual harassment, disability discrimination).  The Government may also be encouraged to change their social policy. This research has identified areas for social change and has either directly or indirectly led to actual or proposed changes in the law.  It has also been partly responsible for improvement in the quality of the protection for legal claimants. Legal representatives have been acquainted with the full scope of legal redress available to their clients. Another feature of my research is consideration of the appropriateness of legal tests or principles to decide an issue (e.g. comparators in discrimination cases).  A substantial part of my research has been concerned with discrimination and the need for equality of treatment within society.  More specifically it is often concerned with protecting someone against behaviour which represents an affront to their person e.g.  harassment, stalking or bullying.  The judiciary is sometimes respectfully requested to reconsider their approach to a legal issue to ensure such victims are given legal protection.

‘race’ and silence: the discourse of reticence
2006
Hall, John
University of Warwick

My understanding of ‘race’ and racism in Britain is that it is discussed variously. Sometimes it steals the headlines as when Stephen Lawrence was murdered (Macpherson 1999). Yet at other times there is a preference not to mention the subject at all. Public discourse on ‘race’ and racism can be reticent. Why is this? Is ‘race’ a difficult subject of conversation? The first chapter of this thesis examines the roots of ‘race’. In Chapter Two the silence and silencing at a public level but also in everyday interaction becomes the focus. Difficult conversations are considered. The dynamic of reticence and fluency in the discourse of ‘race’ is explored and conceptualised with reference to the limited material in the literature on the silence and silencing of ‘race’ discourse. This raises the question as to who is responsible for silence; and, whose interests, if any, might be served. Chapter Three presents a real world enquiry – the Swapping Cultures Initiative in Coventry and Warwickshire; involving over 1,000 children and young people that took place mainly between 2002 and 2004. It reveals that a significant proportion of participants (3 8.1 %) experienced bullying, racism, or being picked on, based on their cultural background, and that these issues are difficult matters for conversation (38%). What is revealed is both the complexity of the participants’ identities and the subtle and sophisticated ways in which their cultural backgrounds are managed through conversation. What then does silence mean when the subject is ‘race’? Certainly it is nuanced and complex. Chapter Four provides a series of concluding reflections on ‘race’ and silence, identifying the major factors when seeking to understand and address ‘race’ issues in their local context. It places centrally the ‘discourse of reticence’ as a significant, hitherto underestimated, element when considering the prevailing and pervading presence of ‘race’ and racism.